September 15, 2004 -- John
Kerry is in deeper trouble than the polls indicate. While the Fox News survey
taken last week after the Republican convention shows Bush with a small lead
over Kerry, the internal data indicates big shifts against the Democrat.
For example, Kerry is now seen unfavorably by a
record 44 percent of the voters (his personal worst), giving him a slightly
higher unfavorable ratio than Bush - whom 43 percent dislike. (Bush's edge comes
from the fact that he gets 51 percent to rate him favorably, while Kerry has
only a 46 percent favorable rating.)
But worse, the poll shows that Kerry must face a
basic problem: His own voters don't like him very much.
The Fox News poll asked Kerry supporters if their
vote for the Democrat could best be described as motivated by support for Kerry
(41 percent) or by opposition to Bush (51 percent). By contrast, Bush voters
emphatically say, by 82-13, that they are voting for the president rather than
against the challenger.
This puts Kerry in a tough position in the coming
debates. He has no real base of support and any attenuation of the dislike his
voters feel for Bush will weaken him substantially. All Bush has to do is to
persuade a few Kerry voters to stop disliking him, and he can get their votes.
There is no residual affection for the Democrat to get in the way of their
switching to the president.
The polls already have shown how Kerry's own voters
break almost evenly on the issues, with half supporting the war in Iraq and half
opposing it, and almost equal numbers saying we must stay the course as say we
should bring the troops home.
So Kerry can't use issues to hold his own in the
debates: Whatever he says will antagonize some of his base. And now it's plain
that he can't rely on personal popularity to hold them, since most are just
voting against Bush.
If the president gives an even moderately effective
presentation and comes across as even somewhat likeable, he can cut deeply into
Kerry's vote.
In addition, the poll shows that there has been a
shift in the issues on which voters are focused. Those who identify terrorism or
homeland security as key issues has risen from 7 percent before the convention
to 22 percent afterward, and issues such as taxes and gay marriage, which did
not make the polls before, now draw 4 percent each who feel they are the most
important issue before the nation.
Asked which is more important in their votes,
national security or the nation's economy, voters split 45-38 for security - a
clear Bush win.
The electorate remains sharply divided in its
loyalties based on voters' perception of the most important issue. Of those who
see security as key, Bush wins by 68-28, while Kerry triumphs among those who
focus most on the economy by 56-19.
Underscoring Kerry's popularity problems, voters
rate Bush better on a host of adjectives. Who is the stronger leader? Bush, by
51-37. Who is more honest and trustworthy? Bush, 42-37. Who will make the United
States a stronger country? Bush, 46-40. Who takes strong stands and sticks with
them? Bush, 56-27.
Kerry only wins "Who understands the average
American better?" - and by only 43-36.
Kerry never had time to make America like him. He
won the nomination before anyone really got to know him and has coasted on
anti-Bush campaigning ever since. Even now, he relies on the old National Guard
records of Bush to animate his campaign, as if we are about to form our judgment
of how Bush would be as a commander based on 30-year- old, possibly forged
records rather than on our own observation of how he has done the job. But Kerry
has got to close the most fundamental gap of his candidacy: Voters don't like
him very much.