active votes
vote archive
discussions



VOTE.COM(tm)
Polls Have Closed
 
YES
A transsexual who underwent a sex change to be a woman is a woman - - and entitled to all rights bestowed upon a widow
NO
Once a man, always a man: no amount of surgery can biologically change a man into a woman - - and such a transsexual should not be considered a widow
 
the issue view results discussions
 
J'Noel Gardiner, a transsexual and the widow of Marshall Gardiner, was Mr. Jay Ball until a sex change operation transformed him to a her


J'Noel Gardiner was 41-years-old when she married her late husband, then 85-year-old Marshall Gardiner.  She was also a transsexual who had undergone a sex change operation.  Formerly Jay Ball, Ms. Gardiner underwent a sex change operation to become a woman in 1994.  After the operation, she obtained a new birth certificate designating her as female in gender from Wisconsin, the state of her birth.  A professor of finance at a Missouri University, Ms. Gardiner met her future husband when he introduced himself to her at a 1998 Founders Day celebration at the college.  The two dated for several months and married later that year in Kansas.  Mr. Gardiner died of natural causes a year after the marriage, but did not leave a will.  Under Kansas law, J'Noel, as the surviving widow, would be entitled to one-half of his $2.7 million estate; the other half would go to Joe Gardiner, Marshall's only child.

Despite her sex change and legal birth certificate, a Kansas district court has ruled that J'Noel is a man.  Because Kansas does not recognize same sex marriages, the court has ruled that J'Noel cannot inherit from her late husband's estate.  J'Noel is appealing the decision.

 

 .


 
 
more info
 
the facts
Because J'Noel is biologically still a man, his marriage to Marshall Gardiner is not recognized in Kansas

the arguments
Marshall Gardiner obviously accepted J'Noel as his wife and so should the state of Kansas

Surgery aside, J'Noel was and is a man and has the XY chromosomes to prove it


 
back to the issue



©1999 VOTE.COM. All rights reserved. Patent Pending. Book sales in association with Amazon.com. Terms under which this service is provided to you. Read our Privacy Policy and view our Security Statement.